| status | Legal Proceedings |
| name | V_SAR Op 10.08.20 B |
| date | 2020-08-10 |
| number_of_people | 85 |
| victims_found | some |
| patrol_boat | Ras el Jadir 648 |
| disembark_place | Tripoli |
| prison | Osama prison, Al-Zawiya |
| related_icao | 43ed4b, 40785B |
| link | https://twitter.com/rgowans/status/1292871793779380224 |
Funded by your donations, this investigation was a success. Donate something to help investigate other rejections!
Illegal pushback coordinated by MRCC Rome. Sighting carried out by the Frontex spy plane Osprey 3.
CASE DATA
White dinghy with black front and back. Departed from Zawiya.
85 people on board, including 6 women and at least 1 child. According to the Libyans, the nationalities of the passengers were: Bangladesh 1, Benin 2, Congo 2, Cameroon 6, Egypt 2, Gambia 1, Guinea 19, Guinea Bissau 2, Ivory Coast 4, Mali 20, Nigeria 1, Senegal 5, Sierra Leone 2, Sudan 12, Togo 2, Burkina Faso 4.
Detected by Frontex’s Osprey 3 surveillance aircraft.
Coordination by MRCC Rome.
Captured on 10 August 2020 by the Libyan Coastguard patrol boat Ras El Jadir 648 (no other migrant boats known to have been captured during this operation).
Landed in Tripoli the same day before sunset.
Operation EUNAVFOR MED Irini logs this incident under code 974: the pushback of 70 people intercepted in international waters, following an alert from the Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre (MRCC) in Rome based on a sighting by a Frontex “Osprey 3” aircraft. The interception was carried out by the patrol vessel Ras El Jadir 648, and the individuals were disembarked in Tripoli.
Operation Irini summarizes the event as follows: “On August 10 at 10:30 UTC, the MRCC in Rome reported that an Osprey 3 aircraft had spotted a rubber boat in distress within the Libyan Search and Rescue (SAR) zone (17 nautical miles at a bearing of 020° from Zuwarah), traveling on a heading of 330° at a speed of 4.5 knots. There were no other surface vessels in the vicinity, and the boat remained buoyant. On August 10 at 14:18 UTC, the MRCC in Rome announced the conclusion of the emergency operation: the rescue was carried out by the Libyan Navy Coast Guard (LNCG) vessel Ras El Jadir on August 10 at 13:35 UTC, followed by a return to Tripoli for disembarkation.”
Operation Irini – data
| Date | 10/08/2020 |
| NMR Evénement | 974 |
| Point de départ | LIBYA |
| Position (## ## N, ### ## E) | 3312N 01234E |
| Port de débarquement | TRIPOLI |
| Type d’embarcation | RB |
| Alerte donnée par | ITA MRCC |
| Sauvetage assuré par | RAS AL JADAR |
| Statut | Ferme |
| Nombre de migrants sauvés | 70 |
| Remarques | Le 10 1030Z, MRCC Rome rapporte la detection d’une embarcation pneumatique en detresse, par OSPREY 3, couleur blanche et noire, en zone SAR Libyenne (17 Nq – 020° / Zuwarah), C : 330°, V = 4,5 nd. No LV, bonne flotabilite. Le 10 aout, a 1418ZS, MRCC Rome rapporte la cloture de l’EV : sauvetage par LNCG RAS AL JADAR, le 10 aout, a 1335Z, puis retour vers TRIPOLI pour debarquement. |
Pushback recorded in the Frontex database:
In addition to Operation Irini, the incident was also recorded by Frontex and Libyan militias, with only minor discrepancies—primarily regarding the number of people on board, which is estimated at between 70 and 85. This is not unusual, as both Irini and Frontex determine the number of individuals based on photographs taken from their aircraft; they often fail to spot those lying underneath others. Libyan militias, by contrast, count the people at the time of disembarkation.
The sighting coordinates align: those recorded by Operation Irini are 33°12′N 012°34′E. These match the coordinates logged by Operation Themis, which recorded the sighting of the rubber boat at 33.216666666600000, 12.566666666600000 (in international waters) via an Operation Themis aerial asset (MAS = multipurpose aerial surveillance).

The Frontex spy plane “Osprey 3” with ICAO code 40785B was flying regularly in August 2020, though often with its transponder switched off. It did so on August 10 as well. In the JORA database, Frontex itself admits to having spotted the rubber boat using its own aerial assets.
Pushback incident recorded in the Frontex database:
| Incidentld | 147596 |
| IncidentNumber | 412099 |
| OperationName | Themis 2020 |
| Incidentld | 147596 |
| IncidentNumber | 412099 |
| Operation Sector Type | SEA |
| Primary Incident Type | Prevention of departure |
| SAR | No |
| Detection By FRX Asset | Yes |
| OtherFrontexAssetInvolvement | No |
| FrontexInvolvement | Yes |
| ReportingCountry | Italy |
| DetectionDate | 2020-08-10T00:00:00 |
| InterceptionDate | 2020-08-10T00:00:00 |
| ReportingDate | 2020-08-10T00:00:00 |
| CountryOfDeparture | Libya |
| DetectionInitiatedBy | MAS |
| Disembarkation | Tripoli |
| TransportType | inflatable/rubber boat/zodiac boat/dinghy |
| num_l_MigrantsDeterred | 80 |
| Detection latitude | 33,216666666600000 |
| Detection longitude | 12,566666666600000 |
| Interception latitude | 33,466666666600000 |
| Interception longitude | 12,583333333300000 |
This was a standard Operation Themis pushback: Frontex’s Osprey 3 surveillance aeroplane spots the boat (Frontex acknowledges this in its operations database (“JORA”), where it is recorded in the column “Frontex Involvement”)’ communications probably pass through MRCC in Rome (JORA records the “Reporting Country” as Italy), who call the Libyans. The whole process occurs under Operation Themis, i.e. it is a European border control operation.
ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS HELD BY FRONTEX
We submitted a request for access to documents held by Frontex, but the information we received was very limited. Frontex identified 21 documents but provided only 3. Portions of these documents were redacted, as they fall under the exceptions set out in Article 4 of Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001.
Access to 18 documents was denied because, according to Frontex:
- They contain information crucial for situational awareness at the EU’s external borders.
- Such information is used for risk analysis and operational planning.
- Disclosing it would compromise the effectiveness of current and future operations, thereby benefiting criminal networks.
- It would reveal Frontex’s internal decision-making process, undermining its independence (Article 4(3)).
The 3 documents provided contain a list of operations that took place on 10 August 2021. The one shown below appears to be the relevant entry, though Frontex provided it with an incorrect date. This is confirmed by the identification number “Irini 974,” which corresponds to the operation from 10 August.

The text, we note, except for the date corresponds to that of the Irini database: “Le 10 1030Z, MRCC Rome reports the detection of a pneumatic vessel en detresse, par OSPREY 3, white and black colour, in zone SAR Libyenne (17 Nq – 020° / Zuwarah), C : 330°, V = 4.5 nd. No LV, good flotabilite. The 10 out, at 1418ZS, MRCC Rome reports the cloture of the EV: sauvetage by LNCG RAS AL JADAR, the 10 out, at 1335Z, then return to TRIPOLI for debarquement”.
VIDEO/PHOTOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE IN THE CASE
There is a large amount of video and photographic material relating to this case online.
UNHCR, IOM and IMC staff were at the port of Tripoli when the pushback victims were disembarked and posted several photographs on social media channels.
UNHCR posted this tweet at the link https://x.com/UNHCRLibya/status/1292870141672390661?s=20 at 19:07 CAT on 10 August 2020. There are 2 photographs (UNHCR photo A and UNHCR photo B):

IOM posted this tweet at the link https://x.com/IOM_Libya/status/1292874188068356096?s=20 at 19:23 CAT on 10 August 2020. There are 4 photographs (IOMa, IOMb¸ IOMc, IOMd):

The Libyans post a thread of 8 tweets, the first of which is https://x.com/rgowans/status/1292871793779380224?s=20
In the thread there are 5 videos at the following links:
- https://twitter.com/i/status/1292887184454934530
- https://twitter.com/i/status/1292892159100805122
- https://twitter.com/i/status/1292895136200916998
- https://twitter.com/i/status/1292897572617691136
- https://twitter.com/i/status/1292919209949831170
This is a compilation of these videos on YouTube:
There are also 9 photographs:









CASE RECONSTRUCTION
Night between 9th and 10th August 2020
23:30 – 2:00 UTC: Between 1:30 and 4:00 Central Africa Time (CAT) a white dinghy with a black front and back part leaves from the port of Zawiya. On board there are about 80 people (probably 85) including 6 women and 1 child. The nationalities of the victims are: Sudan, Egypt, Senegal, Burkina Faso and other nationalities that interviewed victims were unsure of.
(Source: testimony of pushback victim)
August 10, 2020
02:54 UTC: Frontex Eagle1 surveillance aircraft with ICAO code 43ed4b takes off from Malta (Source: flight tracking data) and flies over the Maltese SAR zone quickly, straight towards Tripoli, at an altitude of 16,000 feet.


03:26 UTC: Eagle1 has arrived at the Libyan SAR zone and switches off its transponder before turning east. (Source: flight tracking data)
04:00 UTC approximately: At around 6 am (CAT) the migrants onboard see a plane flying over their boat
(Source: testimony of pushback victim)
04:21 UTC: Eagle1 turns its transponder back on. It is located at 33.521, 14.129, flying at low altitude (2000 feet) towards the west. (Source: flight tracking data)
Between 04:29 and 07:31 UTC: Eagle1 switches off its transponder again. (Source: flight tracking data)
07:31 UTC: Eagle1 is now much further east than its previous position: it is flying at high altitude and is returning north. (Source: flight tracking data)
08:12 UTC: Eagle1 lands in Malta. (Source: flight tracking data)
The whole flight path of Eagle1:

Around 10:00–11:00 UTC (12:00–13:00 CAT), the migrants are overflown by another aircraft. (Source: testimony from those who were pushed back)
Before 10:30 UTC: SIGHTING BY OSPREY 3 at coordinates 33.199925, 12.566283.

NOTE: The Frontex spy plane “Osprey 3” (ICAO code 40785B) was flying regularly in August 2020, but with its transponder switched off, including on August 10.
On August 5, 2020, Osprey 3 arrived in Lampedusa from the United Kingdom. In the days that followed, it kept its transponder turned off the entire time. The first detection occurred on August 12, when it appeared for a few minutes within the Libyan Search and Rescue (SAR) zone.
10:30 UTC: The MRCC in Rome reports that OSPREY 3 has sighted a rubber boat in distress—black and white in color—within the Libyan SAR zone (17 nautical miles, bearing 020° from Zuwarah); course 330°, speed 4.5 knots. No casualties; the craft remains buoyant. (Source: EUNAVFOR MED).
Nearby, in the vicinity of the Sabratha platform—17 to 33 nautical miles from the location where the rubber boat was sighted and intercepted—there are three Italian cargo vessels: Almisan, Asso Ventinove, and Asso Trenta. It is unknown whether the MRCC in Rome has contacted them.
13:35 UTC: CAPTURE. The migrants are captured by the Libyan patrol boat Ras El Jadir 648. (Sources: testimony from those pushed back, and EUNAVFOR MED).
During the capture, the Libyans photograph the dinghy in the sea (Source: https://x.com/rgowans/status/1292871793779380224?s=20 )

16:00-16:30 UTC approximately: (18:00-18:30 CAT) Ras El Jadir lands at the port of Tripoli.
Timing of the arrival in Tripoli:
UNHCR released 2 photos of the disembarkation on 10 August 2020 at 17:07 UTC (19:07 CAT). So the arrival and disembarkation occurred before this time.

The photos showed UN agency/NGO disembarkation procedures that were already advanced, and victims leaving the boat. The Libyans have several videos of identification procedures that took place onboard the Ras el Jadir patrol boat while anchored in the port of Tripoli, these identification procedures therefore occurred prior to disembarkation.
We estimate that the identification procedures on board lasted a maximum of one hour. This places the arrival of the Ras El Jadir in Tripoli at around 16:00-16:30 UTC.
The landing phases:
The patrol boat Ras El Jadir 648 enters the port of Tripoli. (Source: https://x.com/rgowans/status/1292887184454934530?s=20)
IOM, IMC and UNHCR staff board the Ras El Jadir patrol boat. (Source: video at link https://twitter.com/i/status/1292892159100805122 )
Upon arrival, UNHCR, IMC and IOM staff distribute food, water, provide first aid assistance and take down the personal data of all passengers. (Source: https://x.com/rgowans/status/1292919209949831170?s=20 – and see the “Port Identification Report” in the attachments)
We have translated what IOM, IMC and UNHCR employees say in this video: https://twitter.com/i/status/1292897572617691136
The first employee asks, “Which part of Sudan are you from?” Another employee asks, perhaps to someone else, “Where are you from?” and a person answers, “Guinea Conakry.” Finally, someone is heard asking, “How much do you pay them?” Unfortunately, there is a lot of background noise and the dialogue is not completely clear.
From the photos posted by the Libyans you can see long shadows caused by the low sun, indicating that the sun had not yet set.

17:56 UTC: ( 19:56 CAT) sunset in Tripoli
In the following hours: From the port of Tripoli, the victims are deported to Osama prison in Al-Zawiya.
(Source: testimony of pushback victim)
PUSHBACK VICTIMS LOCATED BY THE JLPROJECT
We have tracked down several individuals who were subjected to pushbacks and have since initiated legal action.
